An argument of the effectiveness of ngos in the government

Dinyar Godrej inspects the charge-sheet against them. An example can be drawn from the apartheid era when activists convinced the state to make some concessions for black South Africans. Conclusion All in all, our findings point to NGO aid not being a panacea for providing better-targeted aid and boosting aid effectiveness.

Successive governments have actively encouraged NGO participation in government departments and on all kinds of local boards.

criticism of ngos in developing countries

Instead of empowering local populations to organise themselves, NGOs provide employment and a sense of purpose for elites with degrees in subjects like development studies.

NGOs are expected to be non-political, but everything they do, operating within highly skewed systems of power, cannot but be political. The cases made against the NGO sector Some critics also insist that the neo-liberal policies advanced by powerful international actors have limited the influence of the state and that NGOs have benefited as a result.

An argument of the effectiveness of ngos in the government

Western commentators have often remarked on the sheer amount of aid they have seen wasted, sitting idly on dockyards, or sold on the black market. Manji argues that NGOs empower people to attain licensed, rather than emancipatory, freedoms. Join our community of development professionals and humanitarians. The whole group of 60 NGOs granted more aid to needier countries, however. Comparing the allocation of Swiss aid by private and official donors. This indicates the limits to autonomous decision-making of NGOs that depend on government funds. The usual report writing, educational and income-generation activities, were just the tip. Sadly, this is not a disinterested field with universal values. So, to turn to the question posed at the beginning: do they help? Increasingly, governments began looking to NGOs to provide cheap services, a role that continues to grow with austerity policies.

Court victories are often hollow. Once again, however, NGO performance did not differ much from their governments'. Reliant on funding to service our own sizeable organizations, we avoid approaches or issues that might threaten our brand or upset our donors.

Problems with ngos

In any case, NGO aid is clustered, and NGOs are deepening the divide between so-called donor darlings and aid orphans. In my opinion and experience, aid is most effective when it is delivered with local training and carried out with local people. Richie Alford is director of research and impact at Send a Cow. Accordingly, the argument goes, they are better aligned to poor people's needs, and suffer from less leakage. But, as aid organisations, we can give the people the skills to take control and have the ability to deliver change. NGOs have achieved much in single-issue campaigning, ranging from the abolition of slavery to the landmines ban and access to HIV medication. Since demonstrating bang for your buck has become all-important, we divide our work into neat projects, taking on only those endeavours that can produce easily quantifiable outcomes. Moreover, NGOs tend follow their peers, probably in order to control risks by hiding in the crowd. These are excellent things, no doubt about it. It thus seems that Swiss NGOs were accommodating government policy rather than trying to excel in places where governance was particularly troubled. I remember Stephen Browne, founder and co-director of the Future United National Development System , telling a story from Kenya, where 18 different types of water pump had been provided by 18 different donors. History, however, teaches us that the exact opposite may be true. Poverty alleviation may be the rhetoric, critics argue, but in practice little that is lasting has been achieved on this front by NGO activism. We trade in incremental change. To do that we need to ensure that it is delivered without strings attached, with a targeted and grassroots approach that seeks to empower people to take control of their lives.

But no assistance is the worse option in this instance. Echoing the words of Richard Dowden, director of the Royal African SocietyI believe that we should not see it as aid but start seeing it as investment. Some critics, however, suspect that the case for NGO aid largely rests on ideological grounds.

Increasingly, governments began looking to NGOs to provide cheap services, a role that continues to grow with austerity policies.

Rated 10/10 based on 55 review
Download
Aid Effectiveness: The Myth of NGO Superiority