Case study of judicial appointments in

district judge appointment process

It has been a very steep learning curve and there is something new to be learned every day. Counsel told me to sit outside which I did but I should have been in court. Vs Union of India UOI [10] struck down the constitution's 99th amendment and the NJAC Act as unconstitutional and void, restoring the collegium system for appointment of judges to the higher judiciary.

We asked about his career path and his experience of the selection process. I am excited about having a different role to play — rather than putting forward an argument, actually deciding on the issues in front of you.

In the fourth judges case, the Supreme Court had itself asked for suggestions from the members of the Bar and other stakeholders.

court case study

The court sought suggestions from the bar for improved functioning of the collegium system. Let no-one think however that the Legal Executive route into the profession is an easy option.

judicial appointment process

I enrolled and studied for my exams by means of correspondence courses now called distant learning and eventually I qualified as a Fellow of the Institute. Secretariat in each state should be headed by a team of senior bureaucrats who are suitably insulated from pulls and pressures by judges, lawyers, ministers, etc.

Any transfer made on the recommendation of the Chief Justice of India is not to be deemed to be punitive, and such transfer is not justiciable on any ground.

The Chief Justice of India constituted a nine judges Bench to examine two questions. This paper also describes with the help of judgments in the three judges case, what constitutes the collegium in the appointment of judges in HC and SC.

Rated 9/10 based on 21 review
Judges Case Studies